According to the International Coaching Federation ( yes, there is one), coaching is an ongoing partnership that helps clients produce fulfilling results in their personal and professional lives. Through the process of coaching, clients deepen their learning, improve their performance, and enhance their quality of life .http://www.julietaustin.com/article-coaching-counseling.html Assuming our employees are our clients, while we coach them we help them to clarify their goals, set plans to achieve their goals, and then taking action on their goals. Managers can lead individuals or teams to achieve goals, support learning and encourage performance and quality improvement.
Counseling, on the other hand, http://coach4growth.com/coaching-skills/coaching-or-counseling-choosing-the-right-performance-coaching-method-for-performance-improvement implies that an employee is deficient in a work area and needs a "course correction" to perform according to expectations.
I found it interesting to note that when I googled coaching vs. counseling what came up most was the difference between a counselor that you would go to for therapy if you were depressed, for example and a life coach. Very few links led me to how a manager decides when coaching vs. counseling is used.
IF you want a dismal view of counseling take a look at this link: http://thepersonalbest.com/TheCoaches/CoachingVsCounseling.html
Turthfully, I use a combination of both most of the time. Even when I have to do a performance development plan because an employee is not doing something to meet certain objectives, I try to coach them as to what skills they might want to strengthen and what goals they might want to set to get better at that particular thing. Unfortunately, sometimes, all the counseling and coaching in the world won't help if an employee does not have the motivation to do something.
I meet with all my staff one to one every year and go over their goals. We talk about where they are and where they want to be and how I can help them. I consider that coaching. I meet with my charge nurses regularly and often coach them on leadership skills or mentor them on things like how to handle conflict. This is where I am helping people grow.
I counsel employees who are tardy, have performance problems, code of conduct problems, etc. This is where I counsel staff. I still think that with my thirty years of professional experience, some of that experience is used during counseling sessions to coach staff to improve.
Either way, it can be a fine line for a manager to walk.
Wednesday, March 30, 2011
Tuesday, March 29, 2011
Interviewing Job Candidates
At Bronson we do group interviews mostly. When I was hired, I first met with the Director, then I met with the following groups: Staff, unit coordinators and charge nurses, other managers and directors, physicians and finally a one to one with the Chief Nurse Executive. so that was six group interviews and two individual interviews. whew!
So I was interested in finding out what the literature says about some of the advantages and disadvantages of individual vs. group interviews. By the way, while searching, I found a site that might be helpful to some of you, which deals with how to prepare for group interview questions, but also has all kinds of advice for interviews. Check it out at: http://www.best-job-interview.com/group-interview-questions.html
Here are some of the advantages of group interviews:
One of the main disadvantages is that it can be intimidating to a cadidate to walk into a room with six people staring at them and asking questions. Sometimes this can lead to a less than perfect performance for some people. We usually try very hard to put someone at ease with humor, casual introductions and letting them know that they can ask questions at any time.
I have lived through many interviews, and frankly, even though there is more pressure with the group interview, I always felt that I had a better chance with a group than one person. If one person doesn't like your outfit, the other six might like your answers!
So I was interested in finding out what the literature says about some of the advantages and disadvantages of individual vs. group interviews. By the way, while searching, I found a site that might be helpful to some of you, which deals with how to prepare for group interview questions, but also has all kinds of advice for interviews. Check it out at: http://www.best-job-interview.com/group-interview-questions.html
Here are some of the advantages of group interviews:
- Questions are thought out and written prior to the interview, so the interviewers can just concentrate on the answers rather than worry about what to ask next
- All interviewers hear the same answers and can ask for clarification at any time
- It does save some time if groups can interview a candidate together
- Every panelist has an opportunity to ask a question
- The group can come to a consensus at the end
- Sometimes individual interviews can become chatty and social. Group interviews tend to get the job done as far as questions and asnwers
- Apples for Apples comparison - A panel interview allows multiple sets of ears/eyes see and hear the same presentation. This is especially true and important if there are many candidates for the role. Each person on the panel will have a different focus or take on what a candidate says or does. This means on the whole, the group will probably come up with a more accurate assessment of the candidate.
One of the main disadvantages is that it can be intimidating to a cadidate to walk into a room with six people staring at them and asking questions. Sometimes this can lead to a less than perfect performance for some people. We usually try very hard to put someone at ease with humor, casual introductions and letting them know that they can ask questions at any time.
Advantage of an individual interview
- In an individual depth interview, the respondent is relating to one person, the interviewer. The clear advantage, in some cases, is that responses are not “contaminated” by other reactions. This lack of contamination is desirable in some situations, since a very skillful interviewer can get the respondent into great depth without distractions, and without having people change or withhold their opinions when they hear what other people have to say.
I have lived through many interviews, and frankly, even though there is more pressure with the group interview, I always felt that I had a better chance with a group than one person. If one person doesn't like your outfit, the other six might like your answers!
Wednesday, March 9, 2011
Staff Recruitment and Retention
I must admit that I come at staff recruitment and retention from a Nursing perspective. At this time, for most hospitals, RN recruitment and retention is a hot topic, especially as we look at the aging workforce in nursing, how we will replace the nurses leaving the field, how to keep the ones we have at the bedside from going to other positions such as management, consulting, etc., and how we will replace the large number of nurses leaving due to the baby boomers aging while there is a shortage of faculty and a waiting list in most nursing schools of at least two or three years.
Bronson, where I work, I think is somewhat sheltered from the problems facing most hospitals, because the staff working there, according to employee satisfaction surveys is very happy working there, the average longevity of the nurses is over 20 years, and we never seem to have a shortage of new nurse externs that want a job at Bronson. However, nationally, recruitment and retention of nurses is becoming a very big problem.
According to an article by Upenieks (2005) http://nu.kku.ac.th/site/researchnu/knowlegd/peple_development.pdf, here are some of the basic challenges that face nursing staff recruitment and retention today. Although the article was written in 2005, the issues it brings up are still very relevant today. Nursing faces the fact that the acuity of patients has increased, resulting in the need for more patient care hours, and more skilled nurses. The growth of nursing opportunities outside the hospital are quite a challenge also. Nurses can go to outpatient surgery centers, doctors offices, ambulatory care clinics. While some of these settings may offer a slightly lower salary, the offer the perks of shorter working hours, no weekends and no holidays.
When it comes to retention, nurses do not just want a good salary, they want to be respected, appreciated, to be part of the decision making process. Nurses today choose hospitals that will give them flexible schedules, increased autonomy, and professional growth in the way of career ladders, tuition reimbursement, etc.
One of the ways that hospitals are addressing the nursing recruitment and retention problem is by becoming Magnet hospitals. That is a post in and of itself, but basically what that means is that a Magnet hospital focuses on a more participative management style, a decentralized organizational structure, adequate staffing, flexible scheduling,
and professional autonomy.
Bronson, where I work, I think is somewhat sheltered from the problems facing most hospitals, because the staff working there, according to employee satisfaction surveys is very happy working there, the average longevity of the nurses is over 20 years, and we never seem to have a shortage of new nurse externs that want a job at Bronson. However, nationally, recruitment and retention of nurses is becoming a very big problem.
According to an article by Upenieks (2005) http://nu.kku.ac.th/site/researchnu/knowlegd/peple_development.pdf, here are some of the basic challenges that face nursing staff recruitment and retention today. Although the article was written in 2005, the issues it brings up are still very relevant today. Nursing faces the fact that the acuity of patients has increased, resulting in the need for more patient care hours, and more skilled nurses. The growth of nursing opportunities outside the hospital are quite a challenge also. Nurses can go to outpatient surgery centers, doctors offices, ambulatory care clinics. While some of these settings may offer a slightly lower salary, the offer the perks of shorter working hours, no weekends and no holidays.
When it comes to retention, nurses do not just want a good salary, they want to be respected, appreciated, to be part of the decision making process. Nurses today choose hospitals that will give them flexible schedules, increased autonomy, and professional growth in the way of career ladders, tuition reimbursement, etc.
One of the ways that hospitals are addressing the nursing recruitment and retention problem is by becoming Magnet hospitals. That is a post in and of itself, but basically what that means is that a Magnet hospital focuses on a more participative management style, a decentralized organizational structure, adequate staffing, flexible scheduling,
and professional autonomy.
Writing Staff job dexcriptions
I have been very fortunate, because every place I have worked has had a Human Resource Department that writes job descriptions. However, as a manager, a few times I have had the opportunity to help write a job description for a new position, or for redesigning an old position that is being recreated into a new one.
Most recently, we had to create a job description for an IT analyst that serves only our area of Obstetrics. The person was already in the position and had been for a few years, but interestingly enough, there had never been a job description for her. Now, she was moving onto another job and we had to fill her position. That was an eye opening experience for me!
First, we had her list everything she did. That exercise turned out several pages. Then we sent that to HR, who separated the list by the tasks that only the person in this position would do versus what someone in another position could do. So in other words, what made this position unique? What SPECIFIC skills, knowledge and ability did this person have to have that was different from any other position in the hospital?
For example, some of her duties overlapped what a regular IT analyst does, so why would we need a special IT analyst for our Obstetrics system? We had to be very clear and definite in our answers.
I found this site http://www.college.ucla.edu/personnel/jobdesc/intro.asp#def that came close to breaking out the parts of her job that we had to address: what she did, how she did it, (methods, tools and techniques), why she did it, and what specific qualifications she had to have to perform the job.
One of the hardest discussions we had was why this position required an RN to do the job. HR felt that any IT analyst could do the job and we felt that it HAD to be an RN in order to understand the nuances of the charting, programming, etc. In the end, we were able to help them see why it should be an RN.
Once we had our part done, then HR had to consider compensation in order to make it fair and commensurate with other similar job descriptions, determine which functions were essential in order to comply with the EEOC regs, decide what abilities were essential, such as there is no lifting required, but the person has to be able to get to different areas of the campus, and they told us that the requirements for the person who would fill this job had to fulfill the essential requirements of the job.
I definitely learned a great deal from this process, and once again realized that we are lucky to work in an organization that has a department that can keep us from making huge mistakes as well as teach us in an area that we know little about.
While I was doing some reading for this post, I also came across another site that has a wealth of information on this topic and many others http://www.shrm.org/Pages/default.aspx ( Society for Human Resource Management). It is truly a great resource for many HR questions and issues.
Most recently, we had to create a job description for an IT analyst that serves only our area of Obstetrics. The person was already in the position and had been for a few years, but interestingly enough, there had never been a job description for her. Now, she was moving onto another job and we had to fill her position. That was an eye opening experience for me!
First, we had her list everything she did. That exercise turned out several pages. Then we sent that to HR, who separated the list by the tasks that only the person in this position would do versus what someone in another position could do. So in other words, what made this position unique? What SPECIFIC skills, knowledge and ability did this person have to have that was different from any other position in the hospital?
For example, some of her duties overlapped what a regular IT analyst does, so why would we need a special IT analyst for our Obstetrics system? We had to be very clear and definite in our answers.
I found this site http://www.college.ucla.edu/personnel/jobdesc/intro.asp#def that came close to breaking out the parts of her job that we had to address: what she did, how she did it, (methods, tools and techniques), why she did it, and what specific qualifications she had to have to perform the job.
One of the hardest discussions we had was why this position required an RN to do the job. HR felt that any IT analyst could do the job and we felt that it HAD to be an RN in order to understand the nuances of the charting, programming, etc. In the end, we were able to help them see why it should be an RN.
Once we had our part done, then HR had to consider compensation in order to make it fair and commensurate with other similar job descriptions, determine which functions were essential in order to comply with the EEOC regs, decide what abilities were essential, such as there is no lifting required, but the person has to be able to get to different areas of the campus, and they told us that the requirements for the person who would fill this job had to fulfill the essential requirements of the job.
I definitely learned a great deal from this process, and once again realized that we are lucky to work in an organization that has a department that can keep us from making huge mistakes as well as teach us in an area that we know little about.
While I was doing some reading for this post, I also came across another site that has a wealth of information on this topic and many others http://www.shrm.org/Pages/default.aspx ( Society for Human Resource Management). It is truly a great resource for many HR questions and issues.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)