I agree with everyone who posted this week, Barry was a great speaker for us, and it Never ceases to amaze me, as long as I've been in management and even having a degree in Human Resources, how much there is to know, to keep in mind and to learn as things change. I guess that's why I'm glad that we have our HR department, whom I call a lot (lately it seems like every day!!) for advice and guidance.
Now on to this week's topic: Performance monitoring
I found this site that is by the author of our book: http://managementhelp.org/perf_mng/perf_mng.htm probably because I googled performance managing instead of performance monitoring. However, I got some great information.
He talks about performance management monitoring activities that ensure that goals are met in a timely and efficient manner.
I will let you read through the site which is chock full of great information and detailed steps. What caught my eye though, was when he described performance evaluations consisting of "ongoing observations and measurements", "ongoing feedback about performance" , the key word being "ongoing."
As a manager, I have more than 70 staff members. Some work days, some nights, some weekends, some are RN's and some are unit clerks, etc. I am not on the unit 24/7 observing all of these people. So the way we do evaluations on our unit is the charge nurses give input, and then the person gets to pick three people who will fill out an online survey and then the unit coordinators pick three people who will fill out an online survey on the person, and then we compile the information once a year and give out the evaluations. We did not use to do midyear evaluations, and I have restarted them, but for the midyear evaluations, we do not go through the same process. So it could happen that at the end of the year, a staff member could be totally surprised to hear what their peers really think. I don't like this method. In fact, I am working to see what I can do on our unit to change some of the system that is in place.
I have always thought that this is not a great way to do evaluations. If the three staff members we pick to do another's evaluation don't happen to "like " the person they are evaluating, they can really mess up an evaluation . If one of the charge nurses happened to catch a staff person on a bad day, and that's all she remembers when she gives information that can hurt an evaluation also. There just seem to be too many subjective factors and there are no real measurable goals. Just expectations that an employee meets or doesn't meet. And minimum work requirements that they have to fullfill. There is very little ongoing evaluation, very little ongoing feedback . Our staff fills out their goals, but their evaluation is not really based on their goals. So for example, one of their goals might be to join a council this year. If at the end of the year they did not join a council we amy remark on their eval that we encourage them to do it next year, but it is not really a black mark for them.
The only ongoing feedback for staff is if I catch them doing something good, and I recognize them for it, or I or someone else catches them doing something bad and then they go into discipline and they get lots of ongoing feedback.
I, on the other hand, as a manager, have certain goals that I have to meet : for example I have to come in at the end of the year at a certain percent within the budget goal. I have to make sure that the staff comes in at a certain percent on certain survey scores. All of my goals have to be "measurable". If my staff actually thinks I am doing a good job or not is measured by an employee opinion survey which if we are lucky more than half of the staff will fill out. So my performance evaluation is not that great a process either. I could accomplish great things during the year, but if I don't meet my three or four measurable goals, my evaluation would be very bad.
Our hospital is a Magnet hospital and I am very proud to work there. We are a Baldridge award winner, which very few hospitals manage to earn. I think we give great care, and I would go there in an instant if I was sick. I'm just pointing out that even great organizations don't have it all figured out when it comes to performance monitoring.
Tuesday, February 15, 2011
Friday, February 4, 2011
Human Resource Challenges for NFP's
I have read the chapters assigned, and found them very interesting and not much unlinke some of the HR challenges we face in our hospital. We too, have to have job descriptions, hire and fire personnel, coach and direct staff, figure out when we need training, education or development, orient staff appropriately, etc. McNamara makes very good points about how to handle all those issues.
However, I wondered to myself, what happens when a NFP doesn't have an HR department? Or a person skilled in HR? Is it different to coach employees or hire and fire them when the salaries are less and/or people volunteer for the sheer passion of the cause? I turned to the web for some answers.
Indeed, I found that especially for smaller NFP's there a many challenges. For example, when you are first starting out, and you have no HR person, who hires staff? How do you write a job description before you know exactly what jobs you will need?
NFP's also have a challenge in that due to funding and sometimes IRS restrictions, they want to find the very best people to do the job, but they can't pay them what for profits can. NFP's very often have to be able to have a cause that attracts people to more for less because of their sense of purpose or passion. As good as that may be when you get the right person, it can cause it's own problems when you hire someone who is passionate but not good at their job. Or when you have a volunteer that is not performing. (centerpointforleaders.com)
One of the points that I read is that NFP's often DO have a little more leeway in the package that they can offer other than salary. For example:
I took the time to look up the survey and if you have the time, it is very interesting. Here is the website where I found it: http://www.nonprofithr.com/clientuploads/2010EmploymentTrendsSurvey.pdf
Did you know that there are over 61 million employees in the nonprofit sector? Wow, that is a lot of HR to handle!! The report includes responses of over 500 non profits accross the country. The survey collects information on staffing, recruitment, staffing challenges, and staffing resource management. Consistent with the economy for companies that are for profit, NFP's have also had to reduce their workforces while having more demand for their services, consequently overworking their staff. The biggest challenges in 2010? Salaries...
In my own personal experience, having someone with HR expertise is essential as a manager. Knowing what you can ask in an interview, knowing how to follow the discipline process, having a resource that you can ask legal questions of is great.
However, dealing with all the regulations and laws in HR as a manager can also be very frustrating. Right now I have an employee that I know is not working out. The documentation, improvement plans, counseling, coaching, more documentation, and effort involved in being able to let go of this employee is unbelievably time consuming and overwhelming.
However, I wondered to myself, what happens when a NFP doesn't have an HR department? Or a person skilled in HR? Is it different to coach employees or hire and fire them when the salaries are less and/or people volunteer for the sheer passion of the cause? I turned to the web for some answers.
Indeed, I found that especially for smaller NFP's there a many challenges. For example, when you are first starting out, and you have no HR person, who hires staff? How do you write a job description before you know exactly what jobs you will need?
NFP's also have a challenge in that due to funding and sometimes IRS restrictions, they want to find the very best people to do the job, but they can't pay them what for profits can. NFP's very often have to be able to have a cause that attracts people to more for less because of their sense of purpose or passion. As good as that may be when you get the right person, it can cause it's own problems when you hire someone who is passionate but not good at their job. Or when you have a volunteer that is not performing. (centerpointforleaders.com)
One of the points that I read is that NFP's often DO have a little more leeway in the package that they can offer other than salary. For example:
- The possibility of flexible hours
- Perhaps the ability to work from home periodically
- The ability to develop marketable skills for the future
- Recognition (this is intagible, but many people do find this an incentive for work
- The possibility of perks such as free daycare, depending on what supporters or donors can offer
I took the time to look up the survey and if you have the time, it is very interesting. Here is the website where I found it: http://www.nonprofithr.com/clientuploads/2010EmploymentTrendsSurvey.pdf
Did you know that there are over 61 million employees in the nonprofit sector? Wow, that is a lot of HR to handle!! The report includes responses of over 500 non profits accross the country. The survey collects information on staffing, recruitment, staffing challenges, and staffing resource management. Consistent with the economy for companies that are for profit, NFP's have also had to reduce their workforces while having more demand for their services, consequently overworking their staff. The biggest challenges in 2010? Salaries...
In my own personal experience, having someone with HR expertise is essential as a manager. Knowing what you can ask in an interview, knowing how to follow the discipline process, having a resource that you can ask legal questions of is great.
However, dealing with all the regulations and laws in HR as a manager can also be very frustrating. Right now I have an employee that I know is not working out. The documentation, improvement plans, counseling, coaching, more documentation, and effort involved in being able to let go of this employee is unbelievably time consuming and overwhelming.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)